Review – World War Z

Zombie cinema has come an awful long way from the no-budget claustrophobia of Night Of The Living Dead to this globe-trotting action horror that’s as epic in scale as it is in expense.

World War Z aims to be the last word in zombie-geddon, but in sacrificing character for spectacle World War Z aims to be the last word in zombie-geddon, but in sacrificing character for spectacle it ends up lacking the bite of the genre’s true classics

World War Z aims to be the last word in zombie-geddon, but in sacrificing character for spectacle World War Z aims to be the last word in zombie-geddon, but in sacrificing character for spectacle it ends up lacking the bite of the genre’s true classics

Once regarded as little more than a niche genre presided over by George A Romero, the zombie flick was reanimated for modern audiences by Danny Boyle in his 2002 horror classic 28 Days Later and since then has lurched its way into the mainstream, to the extent that even TV has embraced it in the form of the hugely popular cable show The Walking Dead, based on the comic book of the same name.

While the undead were doing their thing on the big screen, Max Brooks’ 2006 novel World War Z took a wholly new and plausible approach by presenting itself as an oral history of a 10-year global zombie war; a collection of personal accounts compiled by a United Nations agent examining the various geo-political, religious and environmental changes that occurred as a result.

Fleeing the initial zombie outbreak in World War Z

Fleeing the initial zombie outbreak in World War Z

Adapting a book with World War Z‘s particular structure was always going to be tough, but it’s nevertheless surprising just how fast and loose the filmmakers have played with the source material, to the extent that virtually the only thing connecting the two is the title.

The novel’s only common thread is its narrator, so it makes sense the driving force for the movie is former UN investigator Gerry Lane (Brad Pitt), who’s portrayed as a loving father to two girls and husband to Karin (Mireille Enos), presumably to remind both us and him what he’s fighting to save when it all goes down.

Devastation-porn in World War Z

Devastation-porn in World War Z

And boy does it all go down right from the first few minutes when, sitting in heavy traffic in downtown Philadelphia, they are suddenly and violently attacked by a growing horde of rabid zombies. The family barely make it to the roof of an apartment complex, where they are extracted in the nick of time by helicopter (whose complement includes a blink and you’ll miss him Matthew Fox) to a US Navy vessel, where they discover the terrifying scale of the worldwide pandemic. Told that he and his family will be forcibly evacuated off the ship unless he co-operates, Gerry reluctantly agrees to join the needle in a haystack search for Patient Zero, starting at a US military base in South Korea. From there, Gerry travels to Jerusalem and (randomly) Cardiff in a race against time to find anything to give them an advantage against “Zeke”.

Karin (Mireille Enos) and husband Gerry (Brad Pitt) seek escape in World War Z

Karin (Mireille Enos) and husband Gerry (Brad Pitt) seek escape in World War Z

A general rule of previous zombie movies has been to suggest the disturbing degree of the outbreak through emergency radio broadcasts or fuzzy television pictures. Not so World War Z, which tries to live up to its hardcore title by wallowing in the devastation, be it the military bombing the hell out of a city or an anthill of zombies furiously piling on top of each other to traverse a massive wall the Israelis have constructed to supposedly keep the undead out. Before you have chance to catch your breath, though, Gerry’s off again on his whistle stop tour.

Going after "Zeke" in World War Z

Going after “Zeke” in World War Z

As the film progresses, however, the focus gradually narrows from CGI-heavy mass destruction and chaos to a relatively claustrophobic third act set within a laboratory, which was bolted on after the movie’s original ending was jettisoned by the studio and producer Pitt.

Gerry (Brad Pitt) and co in World War Z

Gerry (Brad Pitt) and co in World War Z

Although clearly financially motivated (a static indoor location is far cheaper than horrendously expensive reshoots on the scale of the rest of the film) and somewhat derivative of many a great horror movie that’s come before, director Marc Forster makes the best of what he’s given and does a solid enough job ratcheting up the tension, although this is dampened by one unintentionally humorous zombie’s endless teeth-clicking.

While Brooks’ episodic narrative gave the reader a thorough sense of each individual and their story, World War Z’s script doesn’t have time for such distractions as character. Despite his commendable efforts to get the thing onto the big screen, Pitt feels like the wrong fit for Gerry. An actor with more range would have better suited the material and given the audience a greater sense of the personal impact this unimaginable horror must be having. And with the exception of Daniellla Kertesz’s Israeli soldier, no-one else is given the chance to make any impact.

Probably the most memorable image of World War Z

Probably the most memorable image of World War Z

Watching World War Z, I couldn’t help having the feeling that it would have worked better as a cable TV mini-series. The famous Battle of Yonkers chapters aside, wherein US soldiers make an Alamo-style stand against tens of thousands of ghouls (which is missing from the film anyway), Brooks’ novel largely stayed away from massive spectacle, concentrating instead on ordinary men, women and children fighting for survival.

As fast-moving as the thousands of undead who swarm across the screen, World War Z aims to be the last word in zombie-geddon, but in sacrificing character for spectacle it ends up lacking the bite of the genre’s true classics.


  1. Sam's Reel Views · June 25, 2013

    I pretty much wholly agree. It’s all spectacle no substance, and even the zombies were pretty basic I thought. All notion of political subtext, and character from the book is mostly missing from a messy script that’s been 3 times rewritten.

    • Three Rows Back · June 25, 2013

      Thanks. It’s got nothing on The Walking Dead (unfair I know as it’s a TV show and so has more more time for character). I see it as an opportunity missed, one that wasn’t helped by a script written by committee.

  2. Terry Malloy's Pigeon Coop · June 25, 2013

    Nice review mate. Getting very mixed reviews this one. I still fancy checking it out though, even if it’s not the deepest story in the world.

  3. CMrok93 · June 25, 2013

    Better than I expected, but still not as good as it could have been had they decided to push up tame rating a bit. Good review.

  4. Tim The Film Guy · June 25, 2013

    Good review, the film was average to good so yeah I agree 😀

    • Three Rows Back · June 25, 2013

      Pretty much agreed with your review really. It could have been so much better.

  5. filmhipster · June 26, 2013

    Couldn’t agree more, this plot would have made a great Made-for-TV special mini series. That way we could have connected with the characters better. Similar to The Walking Dead.

    Fun summer film though, nothing special.

  6. sanclementejedi · June 27, 2013

    I ended up liking this film a lot more than I thought I would. However, this film settles for being good rather than being great. I really want to see the scenes that got cut from this film.

    nice review

    also agree about this being better as a show on HBO or something similar.

    • Three Rows Back · June 27, 2013

      Cheers. I think it could have been great as a HBO show. It could have been a great film actually, but wasn’t nearly daring enough. I definitely think Brad Pitt’s heart was in the right place on wanting to make it work though.

      • sanclementejedi · June 27, 2013

        Brad certainly was not the problem with this film.

  7. The Northern Plights · September 11, 2013

    I am half way through the film, I’ve not read your review yet…I hope you write what I am thinking.

    The Dippylomat, Esq.

  8. The Northern Plights · September 14, 2013

    Meh…interesting to see that the battle for ‘who can sound the most like GSY!BE for post-apocalyptic soundtracks’ still rages – give it up, none of you have ever even got close. It was a tad too cliché-ridden for my tastes. I tend to fear the ‘lab scenes’ in viral nightmare flicks, but Peter Capaldi saved the day here. Quite liked the spasmodic bonkerific movements of the rabid undead, but the fast forwardness of the finalé felt all a little ‘Oh, fuck, I’ve only got five minutes to finish my homework’.

Leave a Reply to Sam's Reel Views Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s